Saturday, April 25, 2009

Cultural Event #3


I went to the Museum of Art to see Dan Steinhilbers exhibit. I know that the class went, but I returned after that to go and study each piece a little more. For me the one that that was my favorite was the one with the lights and how they looked similar to rain falling. For me that was just a huge comfort, it reminded me of where I grew up. When teaching my class, I hope to be able to teach the children that art isn't just to be looked at, but sometimes it may have more of a meaning for you if you take the time just to stop and look, not just see.

Cultural Event #2



I know, I postponed typing this till the very end. I went to the 5 Brown concert on March 11. For those of you who don't know the 5 Browns are a group of kids, all siblings, that grew up here in Alpine UT. All 5 of them attended Julliard School, of Art, Music, and Theater. Their goal is to get children to like classical music. So for Valentines day I got two tickets to go and see them. I have always liked classical music, but once I heard the Browns I remembered why I loved it. They have done concerts at many different Elementary schools, middle schools, and high schools. I know that for me personally I would bring my children to go and see them perform.

Cultural Event #1

I went to the photo teachers education night back in January or February I don't remember exactly when it was. From going to this workshop I learned that children see things differently than what adults do. I have always known it, but seeing the pictures captured, they turned out beautiful, but it is something that me personally I would never have taken a picture of it. But I realized that I will try and have a photography section for my class. If I needed to I would tie it into nature somehow.

Lesson Plan for Ecology and Complexity

Tiffany & Nichole
Ecology and Complexity Theory and Science
Exploration: Students will explore the Ecology and Complexity Theory.
Objective: Students will be able to understand the Ecology and Complexity Theory and how it applies to a natural habitat.
State Standard:
Grade: 4 Art
Standard: 1
Objective 1- Use value, color, and texture to create interest
Grade: 3 Science
Standard: 2
Objective 1- Classify living and nonliving things in an environment. Identify characteristics of living things (i.e., growth, movement, reproduction). Identify characteristics of nonliving things.
Classify living and nonliving things in an environment.
Objective 2- Describe the interactions between living and nonliving things in a small environment.
Identify living and nonliving things in a small environment (e.g., terrarium, aquarium, flowerbed) composed of living and nonliving things. Predict the effects of changes in the environment (e.g., temperature, light, moisture)on a living organism.
Observe and record the effect of changes (e.g., temperature, amount of water, light)upon the living organisms and nonliving things in a small-scale environment.
Compare a small-scale environment to a larger environment (e.g., aquarium to a pond, terrarium to a forest).
Pose a question about the interaction between living and nonliving things in the environment that could be investigated by observation.
Artists Discussed:
Andy Goldsworthy,
Harrell Fletcher and Miranda July,
Michel Swaine,
Mel Chin,
Christo and Jeanne-Claude
Other Subject Connections: Science: Ecology
Teacher Visuals/ Supplies:
PowerPoint on Ecology and Complexity Theory,
crayons,
paper,
scissors,
glue,
large piece of blue paper
Preparation: Set the blue paper in a central location, set the glue next to the blue paper, have items with different textures available to use as a rubbing, have scissors, crayons, and paper at students desks.

Student Materials:
Different Textures
8x11 white paper
Crayons
Big piece of Blue paper
Scissors
Glue sticks
Pictures of different habitats

Lesson Sequence:
Discuss the idea of Ecology and Complexity
Discuss Harrell Fletcher and Miranda July, and their Learning to Love You More project, and how they don’t know the outcome or what people may get from it, but talk about how the website effects many different people.

Discuss Andy Goldsworthy and how he uses things found only in nature.
If you needed to add in another subject you can talk about the different habitats of animals, we used the ocean habitat. You can talk about how things are intertwined and with slight changes the entire habitat can be changed.

Talk about the difference between living and non-living organisms.
Get pictures and have the students indentify the living and non-living organisms.

Assessment:
Discuss what a habitat is, and how it can be affected by simple things, like a change in the temperature.

Have students find textures in the room or outside and create a texture rubbing, after creating the texture rubbing have the student cut out a shape of something found in the ocean. Have the student paste their cutouts on the blue paper to create a habitat for the ocean.

Resources:
Nga.gov
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andy_Goldsworthy
http://leslieschachter.wordpress.com/2008/11/24/profound-people/
www.pdx.edu/.../majors-programs-fact-sheets
http://www.schools.utah.gov/curr/sci/elem/default.htm
http://www.softpedia.com/screenshots/DPSM-Underwater-Ocean-ScreenSaver_1.jpg
http://media-2.web.britannica.com/eb-media/35/62235-004-184F1FEC.jpg
http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.growseed.org/pond.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.growseed.org/aquaponics.html&usg=__LxX7-pA2AzTC8b0PgqCnASrVXw0=&h=360&w=358&sz=67&hl=en&start=3&sig2=6YCs5ra0ylKBwqX4cINiFw&um=1&tbnid=r9mpucdc7YsttM:&tbnh=121&tbnw=120&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dnatural%2BPond%26hl%3Den%26safe%3Dactive%26um%3D1&ei=153fSZv0OoH-swORnPmjDg
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miranda_July
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harrell_Fletcher
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mel_Chininsideartneworleans.blogspot.com/2009/02/febr...
http://images.google.com/images?hl=en&safe=active&rlz=1T4DKUS_enUS227US228&um=1&sa=3&q=mel+chin+%2B+revival+field
http://report.aruna.ir/pic/Christo%20and%20Jeanne-Claude.jpg
http://www.nyc.gov/html/thegates/images/photos/04_running_fence.jpg
Gardener’s Art Through the Ages: 11th edition
http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.nga.gov/exhibitions/2002/christo/images/large/67.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.nga.gov/exhibitions/2002/christo/67fs.htm&usg=__ezlvao3A4ibzPqxa8pahRatmKtI=&h=389&w=505&sz=55&hl=en&start=11&sig2=dsAp7M2dUGZLueMjCvVU9w&um=1&tbnid=_lEO86nkOCFgZM:&tbnh=100&tbnw=130&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dchristo%2Band%2Bjeanne%2Bclaude%2Bvalley%2Bcurtain%26hl%3Den%26safe%3Dactive%26rlz%3D1T4DKUS_enUS227US228%26um%3D1&ei=qbPfSZXjFJ2MtgPet5CeDg
http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/ideas/brainiac/christobisquayne.jpg
http://www.christojeanneclaude.net/sharedMedia/runfen/thumb/RFlightWickTHU.jpg
http://www.econsciousmarket.com/eco-times/wp-content/uploads/2008/07/umbrellas-by-jeanne-claude-christo.jpg
http://www.ashevilleart.org/images/stories/wrappedcoast.jpg
http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://boingboing.net/images/spiral-jetty-08.jpg&imgrefurl
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Smithson





Comment by Kim Brown
Wonderful lesson girls. Great way to end off the year. For an older class, I would love to discuss the complexity theory and let them come up with their own complexity projects that follow the four parts as we discussed. I would also love to have them decide what subject matter to focus their project on, whether it be a topic we are discussing in history, science, literature, or something they just want to learn/create/do. I could do the project we did with the class to help them get started, or even just discuss it.

Comment by Brittany Crowder
I thought you guys did an awesome job teaching this lesson. I really enjoyed the art project at the end and thought it was fun that the entire class could contribute to one piece of art. In my own classroom, I think it would be fun to have the students create a few different habitats. For example, they could create the ocean (like we did), do land animals that live near the ocean, and then do the sky.

Comment by Karyn Alvey on
Amazing job ladies! I really loved it. Having the art project be a combination of everyone's contributions was a great idea. I also really liked how each person was supposed to find a different texture. It created a fun final touch to it all. The artists included in your lesson are fascinating. I love the "Learning to Love You More" website. What a cool idea! I also really liked Andy Goldsworthy and his artwork. The ice sickle sculpture was awesome. :) Fun artists. I really like the idea of spontaneous learning. One thing I'd like to do in my classroom is to have a thing similar to the "Learning to Love You More." At the beginning of the year, everyone could come up with an idea for an assignment, and then each week throughout the year, we could have a time set aside to do that assignment. Excellent Job girlies!

Comment by Natalee Biggs
Fun lesson girls! I loved the art project that we did as a class. Its great to do projects that everyone is a part of. I think it would be cool to use Andy Goldsworthy to talk about nature and the environment. This could lead to a discussion about doing eco-friendly projects. Recycling could be incorporated and we could use old newspapers to create collages and other projects. The crocheting with plastic bags could also be used. I also like the idea suggested by Brooke that students create art pieces made with only materials found in nature. The ideas about students creating their own complexity projects are really awesome and I think they would be a great thing to include in the classroom.

Comment by Brielle Romney
Great lesson! I think to further the lesson, I would pose the question to the kids of what life would be like if either everything was living, or everything was non-living. Since we live in an environment with both living and non-living things, what would it would be like if the 2 were no mixed? Have them come up with their own ideas of worlds with exclusively living or non-living things, draw a picture of it, and present/explain their theory to the class.

Comment by Amanda Morgan
Wow such a cool theory! I just thought of a really interesting way to connect the kids to this theory. I think it would be so much to take the students to a University or any kind of college and see how everyone acts around each other. This would definitely show how people work together in a community because here at BYU we are our own little community. We could take what we see on the University level and bring it into out Elementary school, making it our own community as well. We can see what animals live around us or in our town. It would be really neat if somehow the students could use one of their talents or abilities to be like a "Michael Swaine" for our school.

Comment by Rachael Haught
I would have them identify communities that they are involved in (Church, family, friends, sports etc) and how they had to adapt when these communities changed ( moving, new friends, new babies etc). I think this would really help them to internalize the idea of communities and the relationships. As a science "experiment" I would have them find an ecosystem they were interested in and figure out the food chain of that system and how they are all necessary!

Comment by Ellen Funch
Before we did an activity for this theory, I would talk to my class about the benefits of becoming involved in our community. We would talk about the things we could do to better the world around us, and hopefully come up with a way to help our community. With this knowledge, we could think of a specific art project to get the community involved. Maybe something with recycling or volunteering somewhere. With all of this we could look at how our community interacted and notice the changes we helped to come about because of our efforts.

Comment by Nayelli Concha
This was a great lesson and a very creative activity!! If I were to use this lesson in my own classroom, It would be a great idea to connect this to other disciplines such as science, ecology, social studies. I think I would a great idea to engage in an activity to learn what things we could do to make our planet a safer and cleaner place! I agree with Ellen in engaging in a community service activity where children can plant trees, learn to recycle or make things out of used paper. I did that with my school!

Comment by Brett Baldry
Your art project is awesome because it allows you to interact and cooperate as a whole group which i believe develops crucial skills in our students. I think it would be really cool to get the community involved as well so the children can see the interest the community has in the school and the children.

Comment by Mandy Turner
I loved how these two topics fit perfectly together. As kids are able to learn about environments through hands-on activities they will have more fun and remember it better. I would have them collectively illustrate the specific interactions in an environment. Also, in order for them to use their imagination, I would have them create their own environment with any texture in the room.

Comment by Nancy
This was a great lesson. It was really fun to make a project as a class together. If we were learning about different categories of ecology we could divide the class into groups and one group could do an under the sea one like we did in class and other groups could do other ones like one with rain forest animals, desert, etc.

Day 14 of Class - 13 April 2009 (LAST DAY OF CLASS!!)

Posted by: Emily Kruszynski:

...today we had a really great presentation by Tiffany and Nichole on the COMPLEXITY THEORY: art that promotes spontaneous learning through:
1. neighboring interactions
2. diversity
3. common ground (allows for communication)
4. decentralized network
We looked at artists:
- Miranda July & Harrell Fletcher (www.learningtoloveyoumore.com)
- Mel Chin
- Andy Goldsworthy (environmental art)
- Christo & Jeanne Claude (large scale, nature awareness)
- Robert Smithson (Spiral Jetty, Great Salt Lake)

We made texture rubbings on things we found in our environment & cut them out to look like sea creatures to make an underwater scene (great way to incorporate art by teaching texture while teaching about underwater life/science) * what I noticed about the presentation that went really well was that it was ENGAGING (lots of questions & class discussion), REPETITION (constantly going over the theory's criteria), & APPLICATION (you helped us apply these concepts to what we were learning & other disciplines). It was very clear & well prepared! GREAT JOB!

Food Presentation


I brought chocolate covered strawberries, sparkling apple cider, and Nicole brought cookies and some more sparkling cider.

Hedonist Theory Lesson

Lesson Plan: Hedonist Theory and Habitats/Environments
—4th/5th Grade
By Kimberly Brown
Exploration: Explore the Hedonist theory as well as Habitats/Environments.
Objectives:
(1) Skills: the student will use collage techniques to create a picture of an environment that would be familiar and pleasing to an animal of their choosing.
(2) Cognition: the student will gain a basic understanding of the hedonist theory, various habitats, and how the concept of belonging ties them together
(3) Affects: the student will explore what is pleasing to them about different art and different surroundings
Time Needed: 60 minutes
State Standards: 4TH GRADE
Standard 5
Students will understand the physical characteristics of Utah's wetlands, forests, and deserts and identify common organisms for each environment.
a. Identify common plants and animals that inhabit Utah's forests, wetlands, and deserts.
b. Cite examples of physical features that allow particular plants and animals to live in specific environments (e.g., duck has webbed feet, cactus has waxy coating). Standard 3 The student will choose and evaluate artistic subject matter, themes, symbols, ideas, meanings, and purposes.
Objective 1
Explore possible content in art prints or works of art.
a. Examine the overall value key of significant works of art and relate the key of each work to a mood.
5TH GRADE
Standard 3 (Expressing): The student will choose and evaluate artistic subject matter, themes, symbols, ideas, meanings, and purposes.
Objective 2 Discuss, evaluate, and choose symbols, ideas, subject matter, meanings, and purposes for students ' own artworks.
• Use a personal experience as inspiration to create a work of art.
• Convey an idea, such as pride or love of one's family, through a work of art.

National Standards:
4TH GRADE NS.
K-4.3 Life Science:
As a result of activities in grades K-4, all students should develop understanding of • Organisms and environments
NA-VA.K-4.5: Reflecting upon and assessing the characteristics and merits of their work and the work of others
Achievement Standard:
• Students understand there are various purposes for creating works of visual art
• Students describe how people's experiences influence the development of specific artworks • Students understand there are different responses to specific artworks
5TH GRADE NA-VA.5-8.5: Reflecting upon and assessing the characteristics and merits of their work and the work of others.
Achievement Standard:
• Students compare multiple purposes for creating works of art
• Students describe and compare a variety of individual responses to their own artworks and to artworks from various eras and cultures
NS.5-8.3 Life Science: As a result of their activities in grades 5-8, all students should develop understanding
• Populations and ecosystems
Lesson Sequence:
a. Introduction:
i. Spread art books of artwork among the class. Let the students decide what art works make them happy and bring them pleasure (See Assessment #3) and share with their groups.
b.
Presentation:
i. Discuss Hedonist Theory
1. What it means—Art should bring pleasure a. Hallmarks of Hedonist Art
2. Rococo, 18th century French Style a. Frivolous and dainty and curly b. Interior Design—form c. Paintings—themes and style 3. How people find different art pleasing a. Point to introduction activity b. Have the students decide if the art lives up to the hedonist theory , “Good or Bad, Happy or Sad?” Game c. Artist that usually brings me pleasure—familiar, Rockwell d. Share what I’ve discovered from asking people e. Share whys—Introduce local artist that has art that brings me pleasure, John Hughes

ii. Transition:
1. Where do you Belong? Ask students if art that brings them pleasure sometimes has a relationship to a familiar place.
iii. Discuss Habitats:
1. What is a habitat—The environment around an animal, where it lives
2. Types of habitats (can be adapted to fit state standards, i.e. Utah habitats or world’s biomes)
a. For Utah:
i. Wetlands
ii. Forest
iii. Desert
b. Questions for each habitat
i. What animals live there?
ii. Why does that animal lives there and not somewhere else?
c. Project/ Demonstration:
i. Prompt: “You are an animal from one of the habitats we studied. Create an artwork that would bring you pleasure because it reminds you of home.” (Show Madagascar clip) ii. Collage type: water color washed background with torn water color on top
iii. Materials:
1. Glue (sticks)
2. Water colors
3. Crayons (optional)
4. “Canvas” Paper and collage paper, 2 sheets of water color paper/per student
***No Scissors Needed***
iv. Demonstration: Review how to wash with water colors. Show the students that simple shapes can be made either by painting them or tearing painted water color paper, giving a textured and interesting look.
d. Work Time: 20-30 minutes e.
Clean Up and Management:
i. Plan on about 5 minutes for clean up (throwing away scraps and putting materials away.
f. Closure:
i. After everything is cleaned up, have the students sit in groups with their collages.
ii. Small group discussion: What animal they would they be, why their animal would find their collage pleasing, and how the collage reflects the animal’s natural environment (see assessment #1).
iii. Class discussion or Personal Prompt (depending on time): discuss or answer personally the following questions. “What is your habitat? Where do you feel you belong? When you see things that remind you of that place, what do you feel? Would you say that art that reminds you of where you belong is hedonistic art? Why or why not?” (see assessment #2)

Assessment:
1) They will also orally share in small groups why their animal would find their collage pleasing and how the collage reflects the animal’s natural environment.
2) They will answer in a short paragraph the following prompt: “What is your habitat? Where do you feel you belong? When you see things that remind you of that place, what do you feel? Would you say that art that reminds you of where you belong is hedonistic? Why or why not?”
3) Students will select art that is pleasing to them, and share why they find it pleasing orally in small groups.

Additional Prompts:
• Start a collection of things that are pleasing to you in a book (You can include art, quotes, photos, and notes, etc). Keep it handy for those times you just need something pleasing to lift you up.
• How would you make a collage of the same biome differently if you were making it from the perspective of a large animal than from the perspective of a small animal?
• What different media, styles, or techniques would you use for each habitats?
• All the habitats have things that may seem negative as well as positive to different people (extreme temperatures, little water, frightening creatures, etc.). Can the whole truth of a place be revealed in an artwork that is always pleasing? What are other problems can you see with using the Hedonistic theory as a basis for art?
Reflections:
Lessons work best when you have some flexibility in the direction you want to go. When I started studying the Hedonist Theory, I was planning on doing an entirely different lesson, but the more I learned, the more natural this direction came. After I went over standards, I just made a few adaptations in presentation to fit, and it still feels natural. Having a big idea concept helps me feel the purpose of my lesson, and see that it is deeper than just an art theory or a science lesson, but a personal connection for each student. I will be better at finding the overarching concepts that create connections for students for all my future lesson plans.

Resources and references: Standards http://www.education-world.com/standards/ Hedonism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hedonism http://www.johnhughesstudio.com/index.htm http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rococo Habitats http://www.surweb.org/ls/ls_view.asp?lsid=2155 http://www.emints.org/ethemes/resources/S00001667.shtml http://www.surweb.org/ls/ls_view.asp?lsid=2100 http://extension.usu.edu/forestry/Reading/Assets/PDFDocs/NR_FF/NRFF... http://www.usoe.k12.ut.us/curr/science/core/4th/4thSciber/4th/envir... http://wildlife.utah.gov/projectwild/magazine/life_zones.pdf Project Ideas http://www.artprojectsforkids.org/



Reply by Nancy
I like how this lesson can really be personal to everyone. If I were to teach this in my class, I would definitely make sure that all of the kids understand that they should do whatever they feel makes them happy so that everyone's projects are different but just a meaningful for themselves. We could really use this lesson for anything... rather than the place that makes us happy or makes a particular animal happy, we could have them create any other thing that makes them happy or gives them a good feeling. Great JOb!

Reply by Ellen Funch
This theory got me thinking alot. The discussion we had in class was helpful to me because alot of times, I feel like life should be really happy but there are times when it definitely is not! It was interesting talking about all of the artists in class that think that art should only portray pleasure. I think this is true in alot of ways, but if we were happy ALL the time, we would become numb to that eventually because we would not have any sadness to compare the happy times to. I think it would be a good time to talk to our classes about our home lives. Sometimes things at home are really great, and sometimes they are not the most ideal situation. The important thing is to find something that makes each one of us happy. I would not really change anything about this lesson plan but maybe add Brooke's idea about creating a completely new habitat where kids could use their imagination to make everything up. I think it would be a good idea for the kids to draw or paint or use whatever medium to show this scene and then write about it in their journals. I was also thinking that I could give the option to the class that instead of writing personally about this in their journals, they could write a letter to their parents and tell them why they made the habitat they did. This would help families to come together, especially if their habitat has their family in it! Great lesson Kim!

Reply by Rebecca Ferguson
This lesson was great. I thought the idea of artwork that pleases us or makes us happy was so interesting. I really think this is a great lesson to adapt to the elementary classroom because it can be interweaved with talking about other differences people have. In addition, I think it is a good learning experience for any aged student because you begin to learn more about yourself.

Reply by Mandy Turner
I love how this lesson explores the habitats of Utah. Because it's something nearby and something the kids can identify with, it will gain and keep their attention. For my class I would discuss the artwork from different time periods that would have been praised by the hedonist theory, and those that were viewed negatively. This will show the students that opinions change over time. One possible prompt is to write/draw something that pleased them as a child and then something they find pleasure in now. They could compare the two and evaluate the differences.

Reply by Tiffany Baum
I loved this lesson, you are amazing Kim. For this lesson, I would have the students create their dream habitat, and what they would want to be in it.

Reply by Brooke Stevenson
Great lesson Kim! For an alternate art activity, I would have students paint a habitat that would bring them pleasure or joy. It would be a habitat that they created on their own, in their own minds. The students could decide which animals would live there, what the climate would be like, what plants would grow there, etc. The animals and plants could be made up or real. Students could even describe how the animals' characteristics are adaptations to that particular environment.

Reply by dan barney
Great idea Brooke! In addition, you could have your students create animals (with the same technique of using watercolor and torn paper... without gluing the animal onto the page) that could survive in different habitats and the student could then demonstrate what adaption could take place for their animal to survive in another student's picture or habitat. It would be really cool to have the students' animals interacting amongst their landscapes in neat ways! Brooke Stevenson said:
Great lesson Kim! For an alternate art activity, I would have students paint a habitat that would bring them pleasure or joy. It would be a habitat that they created on their own, in their own minds. The students could decide which animals would live there, what the climate would be like, what plants would grow there, etc. The animals and plants could be made up or real. Students could even describe how the animals' characteristics are adaptations to that particular environment.

Reply by Amanda Morgan
This lesson was amazing! You did so great Kim! For my addition to this lesson, I would love to take the kids on a field trip or around the school and have them paint on site. I would take them to a place that is beautiful and makes them feel good. This could be anywhere from a park, the mountains, a garden, etc. I could even transform the classroom into a happy place by using a projector and projecting a scene on the wall. Doing this inside the classroom would transform the room into this new place. It would be a good idea before hand to do an activity/journal that asks the students what places brings them pleasure and joy. Then after that is done, I can take their answers and compile a couple places that we could go to (if close by). After we figured out a place to go, I would have them put people or animals in it. It could be their families, friends, pets, etc. This would show them a place and environment that brings them happiness! I know the kids would enjoy this because just thinking about this idea has gotten me excited and wanting to do it!

Reply by Brielle Romney
i loved the lesson! if i teach this lesson, i would be sure to emphasize that it's okay for everyone to have different opinions on the matter, and what makes one person happy may make one person sad. I feel as though some art that makes me happy can make others sad, and maybe it varies depending on the perspective you take on it. To stress this point, I would probably have kids find some sort of artwork that they think is happy because it reminds them of a personal experience they have had, or a happy memory or some sort. An art work that makes them happy based on a past happy time in their life. So the kids will be able to see that some artwork that others may not think is happy, can make one happy based on their background and perspective.

Reply by Brittany Crowder
I thought you did a great job handling this all on your own! In order to make this lesson for my own classroom, I would possibly have the students research an animal, and make sure they each had a different one. They could do the research for curriculum with science, integrate writing for english, and then do the art project with more knowledge of their animal.

Reply by Natalee Biggs
Nice Work Kim! I would use the Hedonist theory to connect to a health discussion on feelings and mental and emotional health. I would lead a discussion with the class about how different things make them feel. I would also do some kind of art project where the students would create an art piece that portrays a certain emotion. I like the ideas mentioned about having the students bring pictures of things that evoke certain feelings or having them create a world where they would feel joy.

Reply by Nichole Mahas
Fun lesson! I think I would direct the students not only to paint in a style that is pleasing to them, but maybe even try to paint in the rococo style. It could be fun for the kids to use pastels and incorporate the themes and decorativeness that comes with rococo.

Reply by Nayelli Concha
This was an incredible lesson! Good job on your presentation and idea of how to apply it! I really believe that art exists for the purpose of bringing pleasure in one's life. I think this can easily be taught to kids since they usually have in mind things that bring them pleasure and makes them happy! Your habitat water painting activity was an awesome way to apply this theory. For another activity I will probably have my students think about one of the happiest moments in their life and make a collage, or a painting or a play dough display and then have them share with the class about this special moment in life that is so important to them. This will be particular significant as they relate art with their life and make more meaningful to ther lives. Painting on site will be another activity I will encourage in my classroom.

Reply by Rachael Haught
Kim, you are going to be a great teacher! I think you did a wonderful job at integrating this theory with natural science. Additional activities I might include would be a scultpure or some form of representational form including texture, color, line, shape etc that would be specific to each student that would represent soemthing that makes them happy or brings pleasure. This lesson would also work great in learning about different cultural experiences/norms. By teaching that art can be anything that brings any one person joy, I think students would also be able to draw conclusions that differences in others can still be accaptable and even fascinating.

Reply by Brett Baldry
I loved your lesson, I thought you did a great job with it. Very detailed with your habitat information. An alternative activity that I would do would be to have them think of a place them brings them the most happiness or joy and have them create that. And then from there you could discuss what type of animals it might be a habitat too.. That way it makes it more of a research type lesson.

Reply by Karyn Alvey
Awesome job girlie! I really enjoyed your lesson. I also really liked the art project we did at the end. I like how we got to choose a place that is meaningful to us and then create it using water color. Good idea with using torn paper! I love the look it gives when you put it on top of the background. As an alternative idea, this could be used in a geography lesson. After learning about the culture and lifestyle of a foreign country, I'd have the students paint one thing that they really liked about the culture. It could be the landscape, the food, a custom, anything really. Excellent job girlie! You did great.

Day 13 of Class - 6 April 2009

Posted by: Emily Kruszynski

...today Kimberly presented on the Hedonist Theory (art that brings pleasure, based on initial reaction, very personal/individual) and we ate chocolate covered strawberries, yummy cookies, and drank bubbly to make us all happy and remember this theory. We then talked about habitat and made watercolor, rip paintings of our "happy place."

Day 12 of Class - 30 March 2009

Posted by: Emily Kruszynski:
...this week in class Kim brought us some yummy pizza to remind us of the New Formalist Theory by using her own ideas/ingredients to create still a pizza, but one that she redefined/made it her own (like instead of using the standard Elements & Principles of Design to describe a work of art, use your own words/new vocabulary to describe it.)

...we discussed Olivia Gude's article Postmodern Principles: In Search of a 21st Century Art Education a little bit (it's a great article on incorporating and redefining art (the elements & principles) in the curriculum).

New Formalist Theory Lesson Plan

Brett Baldry , Brittany Crowder
New Formalist Geometry Lesson
4th
30-45 minutes
Exploration: Students will explore the New Formalist Theory.
Objective: When finished with the lesson we want kids to be able to understand New Formalism and how it relates to life through geometry.
State Standard:
Grade 4 Visual Arts
Standard 2: Objective 1- Analyze and reflect on works of art by their elements and principles.
Grade 4 Mathematics Core
Standard 3: Objective 1 Identify and describe attributes of two-dimensional geometric shapes. Question of Inquiry: How could you critique art using the New Formalist Theory.
Arts Discussed: Michelangelo, Olivia Gude, Lee Quinones

Other Subject Connections: Geometry
Teacher Visuals/ Supplies: Power Point on New Formalism
Preparation: Cut out different shapes for kids to create a mosaic using these shapes. Student Materials
Scissors,
glue,
8*11 sheet of paper for each kid
Pencil Crayons
Lesson Sequence: Start by asking the class the question “What is Formalism?” Once they have an idea of formalism move onto the question “what is new?” From there form a definition of the New Formalist Theory
Then have two opposing pictures. One being a piece of New Formalism art and one being Formalism. Have the class see if they can pick out which piece of art would be the New Formalism. Ask the class questions that will get them thinking more about the context and history behind the piece of art that you have chosen. Once again explaining that New Formalism brings in new features other than line, color…
Show pieces of Olivia Gude’s Art or Lee Quinone’s art. They are New Formalists. Discuss with the class how their art brings in more context or meaning.
Ask the class what are some other things in our lives that have good form but also have great meaning to us… Religion. Open the class up for discussion. If you wanted to tie in other cores you could talk about geometry. Talk about how in formalism you use simple geometry like shapes. But in more advanced geometry classes you start to give these shapes meaning by giving them angles and lengths. By giving them more detail we can then use them as a mathematical tool in our lives. Assessment: -Class discussion about the artists (what did they like? how did each artist’s culture influence his/her work?, ect.) - have kids volunteer to discuss their mosaic, and what it means to them.

Resources: Formalism, picture of formalism: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formalism_(art) Michelangelo’s David: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_(Michelangelo) Olivia Gude: http://www.uic.edu/classes/ad/ad382/sites/Olivia/OG_01a.html Lee Quinones: http://ps1.org/exhibitions/view/147 http://www.leequinones.com/index.php?page=about http://www.absoluteastronomy.com/topics/Lee_Quinones DC Temple Pic: http://www.foulgerpratt.com/const_projects/washingtondc_temple.php



Reply by Mandy Turner
Great lesson!I loved doing the mosaic so much that I put it up on my fridge!One thing I love about this theory of art is that instead of just passively viewing a piece of art as good or bad, you are able to look at each element it contains. For kids who are just building their confidence in their artwork it's good to emphasis the fact that certain elements were considered essential previously and that they themselves can decide on elements that mean something to them. Mosaics allow a lot of creativity without the frustration of mastering a paint brush. For my own class I would have the kids look at different shapes and think of what emotions they invoke, (Circle-happy, relaxed, Rectangle-powerful) and then have them create a mosaic using those shapes to emphasize that emotion.

Reply by Brett Baldry
To change this lesson to be more effective I think that next time I would make it more of a community involved activity instead of just individual mosaics. I think that it reflects more on the meaning of new formalism.

Reply by Nancy
You girls did a great job with this theory. Another really fun thing to do would be for the whole class to create a mosaic design together. I think this would be a great lesson to teach how art has other meaning besides being great art and this could make for a great discussion even in an elementary classroom.

Reply by Ellen Funch
I am actually really excited about this idea and theory! For another spin on the lesson, I would have kids find their favorite piece of artwork and bring a picture of it into class. In class, i hope we would have already talked about Formalism and the themes behind that so they will already know about line, shape, color, form, and texture. By having them bring in their favorite picture, I would have them analyze what characteristics they liked about their picture but I would have them use other descriptive words besides the themes for Formalism. Once the kids used a couple of new terms to describe their artwork I would try and collect all of the new standards as a class in a discussion and we could make bulletin boards from these ideas. On one side of the room, we could have Formalism and those characterizations and on the other side, we could have New Formalism and our new descriptives for criticizing art and have our favorite pictures on both sides! Hopefully that makes sense because it sounds super fun to me! Great job girls!

Reply by Rebecca Ferguson
I thought this lesson was so interesting. I loved the mosaic idea and really thought it went so well with the points being made in the lesson. I think an idea to make this lesson more applicable to students is making the mosiacs more meaningful. I think it would be interesting to pose a question like "what is important to you about your community" or "what do you think of when you think about your friends".. and then respond by making a mosiac.

Reply by Mandy Turner
Great lesson!I loved doing the mosaic so much that I put it up on my fridge!One thing I love about this theory of art is that instead of just passively viewing a piece of art as good or bad, you are able to look at each element it contains. For kids who are just building their confidence in their artwork it's good to emphasis the fact that certain elements were considered essential previously and that they themselves can decide on elements that mean something to them. Mosaics allow a lot of creativity without the frustration of mastering a paint brush. For my own class I would have the kids look at different shapes and think of what emotions they invoke, (Circle-happy, relaxed, Rectangle-powerful) and then have them create a mosaic using those shapes to emphasize that emotion. Sometimes kids can feel their classes are irrelevant if they can't see the connections. By connecting geometry and art, two subjects that may not be enjoyed, students can feel like the information is worth something. In my class I would take the geometry connection a bit further by examining New Formalism in architecture throughout various ages so that I could tie in history.

Reply by Tiffany Baum
For this lesson I wouldn't really change much, they did a great job of presenting it. Really the only thing that I can think of that I would do differently is I would stick with maybe one artist and focus on their type of work, and after the kids grasped that artist give them another and see if they can see the differences but also see the similarities.

Reply by Kim Brown
I really enjoyed this lesson. To add to the lesson I really like the idea of a class cooperative mosaic. Maybe do it in small groups of 4 or 5, and the words or pictures they create for the mosaic can be a message they want to rest of the class to know, or something for the school at large. I would also have students discuss a piece of artwork using the vocabulary of Formalism, and then have them describe the same artwork without that vocabulary, in a different way, so they can participate in New Formalism.

Reply by Brooke Stevenson
Good job teaching a hard theory. I loved making the mosaics. To adapt this to my classroom I would have students decide what formal criteria is most important to them in art, not including the basic formal elements. Then they would use their own standards to judge different art pieces shown to them. For example, one student might choose to look at brightness, balance, denseness, and radiance. They could also use these elements in creating their mosaics.

Reply by Nichole Mahas
What an interesting lesson. I think I would have the students pick two works of art, one traditional formalism, and one that they think is new formalism. I would then have them share with the class the differences between the two works and why they placed them in the categories they did. I would be sure to encourage the students to explain how line, form and theme of the work adds to weather it is formalism or new formalism.

Reply by Brittany Crowder
In order to change this lesson, or make it better, I would definitely still keep the mosaic project, but have them make it more meaningful to them in their community. In order to do this I could have them brainstorm as a class feelings they have at school and being a part of this. They could each make a part of the mosaic and then combine them into one large mosaic.

Reply by Jessica Morgan
Hard theory! But I thought you did a great job explaining it. I would like to extend the mosaic area of this lesson a little more. I would go into the history of mosaics and study the different shapes that have been used. I would show my students different kinds of mosaics so that they could get an idea of how they want to put together their mosaic. I think it would be good to tie in another subject with the mosaic as well.

Reply by Amanda Morgan
This theory was very interesting! But you girls explained it very well!! I loved the idea of posing the question of what formalism is to the class and what the meanings are to it. Children may have a hard time understanding this theory but I think with examples that we talked about in class, they would understand it better. I loved the Mosaics that we did in class. It would be fun to make one as a class, or as a school, or even as a town. There could be one theme around the whole piece of art that would or could describe the town or the school. It would show what is most important to them. We did this in my home town except instead of a mosaic we did a mural painting. It was amazing and beautiful and everyone got to help out! It would be fun and interesting if the children thought of ways to describe the piece of artwork without using the regular terms for it. Having them come up with their own vocabulary words would help them to remember it and apply it more to their art criticism.

Reply by Karyn Alvey
Great job girlies! I thought your lesson was really good. What an interesting theory! I really like the idea of this new way of thinking. It's interesting that we've all learned the basic qualities in art, but maybe we're missing something just as important. Also, I loved the mosaic idea. They were really fun to make. Everyone's were very individual and unique. It was cool to see the different meanings and thoughts we each focused on. An adjustment I would make to the lesson would be to apply it to English. An idea could be to read a book as a class, have a group discussion about what main points the author was trying to teach. After getting the main points, figure out some not so obvious ones. Relate these lessons to the students' lives to help make it more meaningful. Great Job!

Reply by Natalee Biggs
Nice work girls! I would show the students pieces of art from a wide variety of different styles and ask them what stands out to them in regards to the form. We would have a discussion about how they would describe the art pieces and what kinds of words they would use to describe their form. The mosaics were really fun and I think they could be used in any subject. I really like the ideas that others have said about making a class or community collage. The students would learn a lot about unity and cooperation from doing a project like that. I also liked the idea of making a mosaic that was more personalized for the student. The teacher could provide an open ended prompt to help the students make a mosaic that represents them or their families. After the mosaics were created the students could write a poem, a story, ect. describing the mosaic using some of the new vocabulary.

Reply by Nayelli Concha
This class was great! I think since this theory only focuses on the formal properties of art just like color, shape, lines, rhythm, I would have many students create any crazy sculpture they want having in mind this idea of shape and movement then I will have them express why they chose to do their artwork with the rest of the class to add a social component to it. The mosaics were an excelent idea! Good job!

Reply by Brielle Romney
yall did a really good job explaining this theory! i really felt like i knew what you were talking about, and could easily teach kids this theory using your lesson. during class, i noticed there were some different opinions on what was "new formalist" and what wasn't. thats the great thing about art - it means something different to everyone. i think i would have kids look at different forms of art, and then give them one art piece to write a paper on, explaining why they think it is or isn't new formalist. i'm sure the kids would come up with different answers, and as long as they back up their answers well, i think they could all be right in their own way. i really loved the lesson!

Day 11 of Class - 23 March 2009

Posted by: Emily Kruszynski:

...today we looked at the NEW Formalist Theory which looks at the formal qualities of an art work using other/alternative elements and principles of design, that have new context or meaning. (For example, instead of saying that an artwork is good because of how the elements of line and color are used to achieve the principle of harmony, you could say that the edges and brightness achieve excitement...or any other new vocabulary that describes the formal qualities of that work.) We made mosaics and next week we will be eating something yummy to remind us of this theory.

...Dan talked to us about CRAFT. We looked at artist Gabriel Craig (www.conceptualmetalsmithing.com) that makes jewelry and we made our own rings out of Fimo and Sculpey. *Finish them, bake them, and bring them to class next week.














Neo-Rationalist Theory Lesson Plan

Becky & Nayelli
Neo-Rationalist Theory and Poetry
Exploration: Students will explore the Neo-Rationalist Theory
Objective: Students will be able to understand the concepts of the Neo-Rationalist Theory and how it applies to writing.
State Standard: Grade: 2 Fine Arts
Standard: 2 Objective 1- Identify significant works of art that have the appearance of depth. Grade: 2 Language Arts
Standard: 8 Objective 1- Prepare to write by gathering and organizing information and ideas.
Question of Inquiry: How can you apply the Neo-Rationalist Theory to your own art, by taking concepts or ideas from other artists and using these aspects in your own creativity.
Arts Discussed: Alexandra Nechita, Picasso, Jackson Pollack
Other Subject Connections: Language Arts: poetry
Teacher Visuals/ Supplies: PowerPoint on Neo Rationalist Theory, Tempur paint, Paper, Paintbrushes
Preparation: Prepare paint and brushes for students to recreate their own Jackson Pollack
Student Materials:
• Tempur Paint
• 8x11 paper
• Brushes
• “Art smock”—Jackson Pollack recreations are messy :)

Lesson Sequence:
1. Discuss the idea of Neo-Rationalism in simpler terms: we adopt ideas from other artists and recreate them in our own way.
2. Discuss Alexandra Nechita and how she is named the “Petit Picasso.” Discuss how she adopted Picasso’s techniques in cubism and invented her own way of art.
3. Ask students if they think this theory of creating their own work by adopting others’ ideas is good or bad. Discuss that some theories are neither good or bad. Discuss the way in which we adopt others ideas in other ways other than art: hairstyles, fashion, recipes, interior design, literature, movies.
4. Discuss that imitating, assimilating then innovating is a way we learn
5. Discuss how we can find our own inspiration through many different mediums.
6. If you wanted to tie in Neo-Rationalism to other cores, you could talk about poetry. You could read a Shel Silverstein or Dr. Suess poem and then have the students recreate their own poem using the same style/format that Silverstein or Dr. Suess uses.
Assessment:
• Discuss Jackson Pollack’s technique of creating his art
• Have students recreate their own Jackson Pollack artwork, but emphasize that they can choose to use any colors of their choice, just adopt the technique of applying the paint to the paper.

Resources: http://www.sojournmusic.com/2008/07/22/imitate-assimilate-then-inno... Teaching Creativity: http://www.goshen.edu/~marvinpb/arted/tc.html Alexandra Nechita and the Petit Picasso: http://www.lewisbond.com/nechita/about_nechita.html Video on Alexandra Nechita: http://www.cnn.com/exchange/blogs/ypwr/2007/11/alexandra-nechita_26...



Reply by Nancy
This was such a fun lesson and project. I think another thing that would be really fun is to take your class outside and make a giant painting all together although it would probably be messy. We could also use this lesson and let the kids pick from a variety of different artists and choose their favorite one and try to create something like them.

Reply by Tiffany Baum
I really loved this lesson, during that class I was having a bad day, so coming to class and getting to flick paint was a great stress reliever. One thing that I would do differently is that I would ask the school if I could take part of the cement outside in front of the school and block it off. I would put up plastic all around it, than I would have the students create their own "Pollack" design out in front of the school so that way the students could keep it there forever. (Or until it gets ripped up.)

Reply by Brooke Stevenson
To adapt this to my own classroom, I would ask students to imitate other artists such as Piet Mondrian. I would have a list of options of different artists to imitate. The students would be able to choose which artist's technique to use in creating their own art. It would also be interesting to try combining two different artists' styles. For example, a student could paint an Andy Warhol can of soup in the cubist or impressionist style.

Reply by Karyn Alvey
I really liked your lesson. I thought it was great! Great job. :) I liked our discussion about Alexandra Nechita. I'm amazed at how young she was when she started painting. I also like how she wants to be known not as the Petit Picasso but as herself. She doesn't want to be connected with Picasso, despite of how famous he is. One of my favorite things about this theory is that it teaches that it is ok to be inspired by something and then add to it and create your own. I don't feel like I'm super creative, so I often rely on getting inspiration from others' works, so I liked this theory:) I really liked the activity. It was a lot of fun and very applicable. Another idea you could implement is to have the students bring in a copy of their favorite painting or picture. Then, have take an element or aspect in the artwork they brought and have them apply it in their own artwork. Great Job!!

Reply by Kim Brown
I would love to have my students imitate multiple artists at one time, drawing inspiration for different aspects of artwork. Perhaps use Leonardo de Vinci's Mona Lisa as the subject, Van Gogh's style or form, but make it out of sculpting clay. Or, to tie it into more curriculum, you could have them use the style of one artist and the mood or tone from a certain piece of literature we have studied to create an artwork about a historical event of figure. That would really cause the students to stretch, but I think they could also really succeed. Actually, this suggestion reminds me of an art work that is in the MOA right now in the Visions of the Southwest exhibit. There is an artist there who was inspired by Van Gogh, and paints in a similar style, but painted the southwest. It is amazing.

Reply by Brielle Romney
i really liked your lesson! since kids are more prone to copy what is put in front of them as opposed to adults, i think it may be a little difficult to get this point across. a way I might try to get students to realize the difference between imitation and their own ideas is to, one week, tell them to draw a certain figure. then the next week (so they can possibly forget about what they had drawn the week before) show pictures of the figure they drew, and then ask them to draw that figure again. then compare both of the pictures they drew. see if kids changed their pictures at all or not, and have a discussion about why they did or didn't. was it because they were trying to imitate the pictures they had already seen? be sure to use the same wording when talking about the figure to draw both times!

Reply by Amanda Morgan
Children are prone to copy other artists when they are younger! It will be hard for them to create their own artwork without having a copy to look at first. I would pick random artists that I have learned about or heard about and have the kids copy their work. I want them to have their own imagination and to come up with their own ideas but to start them off I would show them a piece of artwork from Picasso that I really like and I would have them imitate his work. The next couple times of doing this I would give them different ideas to draw. I don't want to get them stuck on only imitating someone else's work! It would be fun to do an activity where we made something like the pizza thing we ate in class! I know the kids would remember doing that and why we did it!

Reply by Natalee Biggs
Great work girls! This is an interesting theory. I would use this theory to lead a discussion with my students to teach them that it is okay to take inspiration from other people. Its good for us to share ideas with each other and try things that others have done. I would discuss the difference between being inspired by others ideas and techniques and just copying their work. I would show the class artists like Alexandra Nechita and discuss how her technique is very similar to Picasso's but she has made it her own. Hopefully through showing many different kinds of examples each student could find something that they like and connect with that they could try and imitate. After imitating for a little bit, we would move on to trying to take elements of the artists they have chosen and create pieces that have a personalized twist to them.

Reply by Brittany Crowder
I thought this lesson was very interesting and and liked learning about the "Petit Picasso". When using this lesson in my own classroom I would for sure use her as an example and compare her to the regular Picasso. I would then use this theory to do an art project. Something fun would be to have the children bring in a favorite painting, picture, sculpture, or anything, and have them do an art project based on what they like from what they brought in.

Reply by Brett Baldry
To adapt your lesson into my classroom I would collect a very wide variety of paintings. I would have all sorts of different types to try and find a painting that each student will have the opportunity to relate to. I would then have them pick their favorite painting and try to imitate it. I think it is awesome that you brough Alexandra Nechita into this lesson because I think it is a great way to show children that they can create art at a young age.

Reply by Ellen Funch
I really love the principle behind this theory that new artwork and creativity often comes through immitating, then assimilating, and THEN innovating! I would have to agree with everyone else's posts. If i were to teach this theory in my classroom, I would have them immitate a drawing but I would love it if they could think about it in their head before. For example, most kids have at least seen the Mona Lisa, but not all of them know exactly what it looks like off the top of their heads. It would be interesting to have the kids immitate a drawing of the Mona Lisa from memory first and then later have them do it again with a copy of the painting in front of them and compare the results. I do not really know what we would teach from that but maybe something science related about our visual memories and how we look at things and what we remember? I was also thinking it would be cool to apply the principle of this theory (immitate, assimilate, innovate) into more ciriculum. We could use what we are studying in history and look at what societies or peoples in history used this approach. For example, the foundation of our country being taken from the principles that ancient Greece and Rome were built upon. It would be a cool project to have a class notice these similarities and maybe draw a picture of life in Greece and life now and accentuate the similarities. Great lesson girls!

Reply by Rachael Haught
After studying various artists and styles I would have the students decide which one they like the best. After choosing their top two I would want them to combine them and make it their very own. Perhaps some students will like Monet and the meaning behind the impressionist movement. But perhaps they do like Jackson Polluck's style; by combing these two movements the students can come up with something very unique and something they can claim as their own!

Reply by Mandy Turner
I think this would be a great lesson for teaching students the difference between plagiarism and adoption of ideas. A class discussion could include comparing novels to their movie version. After introduction of various artists, each student can pick their favorite and adopt some aspect of their artwork to implement in their own work. I like the idea of connecting poetry with it so that kids can have a better idea of how to write poetry they enjoy instead of just being assigned a topic or structure.

Day 10 of Class - 16 March 2009

Posted by: Emily Kruszynski:

...today we looked at the Neo-Rationalist Theory & ate home-made, Martha Stewart oreos to remind us that according to this theory, art is good art if it is patterned after/influenced by/similar to a famous artist's work (like Alexandra Nechita's Picasso-like paintings) & painted our "own" Jackson Pollock paint splatter paintings. ...then we made photo-grams (also called Rayo-grams) where we put objects on photo paper (that was treated by chemicals) out in the sun to make some cool "photography" (great way to teach your students about photography, etc)
...to make a Photo-gram:
1. inverse copy (negative copy) an image in black & white on overhead paper
2. coat regular white paper with a mixture of Ammonium Iron Citrate & Potassium Ferricyanide mixed with distilled water using a sponge brush
3. let dry in light-tight room (dark room)
4. take outside & arrange objects on top (let stand for 5-15 mins)
5. rinse in water (5 mins)
6. immerse in diluted hydrochloric acid
7. let dry
...we talked about Constraints to enable new understanding (alternate/additional lesson ideas):
1. see prompt
2. collage
3. photogram an object (on top)
4. incorporate words

Posted by Dan Barney: This is where I usually order my Cyanotype kits from http://www.freestylephoto.biz/sc_search.php

Cyanotype:




Posted by Dan Barney:

Guess where I went this weekend!!! I thought of all of you so I took this picture in front of a big Pollock painting so you could see the scale.

School of Criticism Lesson Plan

Teacher: Brielle Romney
Criticism in Schools
Lesson MATERIALS:
Ribbon glue
Magazines paper
Small containers
Scissors
-Bring in magazines, have them decide what is beautiful and ugly and tell why -Prompt: What makes art good or bad? -What is art criticism: explain, interpret, and evaluate artworks by writing or speaking “We can then look at an artwork and use the inherent qualities as a basis for judgment.”
-What is it NOT: expressing random feelings, stating personal preferences -4 styles of art -4 stages of criticism
-Divide class into 4 groups with 1 painting from each genre, they figure out what genre it is and then try to persuade the class to buy it based on the inherent aesthetic qualities they’ve been taught, rest of class guess what art style it is based on selling points of presenters
-Critics:
-Past vs. Present Critics
-Relation to Language Arts
-Activity
– “art criticism containers”
- need a small container (with a completely removable lid), ribbon, scissors, paper, glue, pictures or anything else wanted. - to make: glue a long piece of ribbon on the inside bottom, and bottom of the lid of the container. Cut pieces of paper that will fit into the shape of the container, and glue to either side of the ribbon. Put pictures, poems, notes, ANYTHING on paper glued to the ribbon. It should kind of “fold out” when you open the container
ENDING Now ½ way to being a critic b/c you know the 4 questions to ask, now just need to learn more art history

STATE STANDARDS
Standard 3 The student will choose and evaluate artistic subject matter, themes, symbols, ideas, meanings, and purposes.
Objective 1 Explore possible content in art prints or works of art.
• Select themes or symbols appropriate for describing an idea or personal experience in art.
• Group artists and their works according to style or similar visual characteristics. Objective 2 Discuss, evaluate, and choose symbols, ideas, subject matter, meanings, and purposes for artworks.
• Evaluate a significant work or works in terms of craftsmanship, concepts, objectives, creativity, beauty now, and beauty when it was created.
• Create a work of art portraying an object or animal important to the student.

LANGUAGE ARTS
Standard 7 Comprehension
-Students understand, interpret, and analyze narrative and informational grade level text.
Objective 1 Identify purposes of text.
a. Identify purpose for reading.
b. Identify author’s purpose.
Objective 2 Apply strategies to comprehend text.
• Relate prior knowledge to make connections to text (e.g., text to text, text, to self, text to world).
• Generate questions about text (e.g., factual, inferential, evaluative).
• Form mental pictures to aid understanding of text.
Objective 3 Recognize and use features of narrative and informational text.
• Identify characters, setting, sequence of events, problem/resolution.
• Compare and contrast elements of different genres: fairy tales, poems, realistic fiction, fantasy, fables, folk tales, tall tales, biographies, historical fiction, science fiction).
• Identify information from text, headings, subheadings, diagrams, charts, captions, graphs, table of contents, index, and glossary.
Identify different structures in text (e.g., description, problem/solution, compare/contrast, cause/effect, order of importance, time, geographic classification).

Comment by Amanda Morgan
This lesson was so great! I really liked how you girls took quotes and notes from the book! Great idea! If I were to adapt this and make it my own lesson I would try and use more criticism in the lesson. We criticize people all the time and I would want the children to realize what they are doing. I would plan an activity where they were given different pieces of art work or clothing or music and I would have them write down their first impression of it. I would then go into the lesson part bringing in quotes about criticism and how we should and shouldn't judge them. I want them to realize that they can appreciate the piece of art before any criticism comes out of their mouths. Loved the activity as well! It has turned out to be so cute!

Comment by Nichole Mahas
Loved your lesson. I think i would have the art project the students create at the end involve criticism. I would have them create a work of art using a certain medium, and then have them criticize their own art work. They would share the basis for their criticisms with the whole class. With older grades I might even have them criticize each other's work just for the experience of interpreting the meaning of other's works.

Comment by Brittany Crowder
this lesson was really good! i really liked how you showed us magazines we could relate to (bridal magazines, haha) and asked us what we thought was beautiful, and then you critiqued it. i think i could make this lesson my own by bringing in different children's magazines or even different toys and asking them what they think are beautiful or what they think is art.

Comment by Kim Brown
I loved the project for this lesson! It is a creative project that sets up anybody for success. To add to this lesson, I would love to have a discussion on constructive criticism and its importance in reviewing, analyzing, and improving our own work, skills or behavior. I also would like to use Nicole's idea of letting the students have a hand in being their own art critics.

Comment by Brooke Stevenson
I would like to discuss how our perception of beauty has changed throughout history and look at art to go along with that. It would also be interesting to look at how standards for beauty change from culture to culture. Then the students could write about what they learned and make their own art that they believe is beautiful. They could compile these and bind them as a book that they could keep.

Comment by Brett Baldry
I really liked this lesson. I think this would apply very well to kids. I thought it would be fun to use this in a self confidence lesson. I think it would be fun to show kids that it is okay to be different and that different people view different things as being beautiful. We just need to find what our own beautiful is.

Comment by Jessica Morgan
great lesson! I really liked when we looked at our paintings and had to categorize them according to the different schools of criticism. I would like to take my class on a field trip to a local museum or art gallery and have them look at the different art works. We could judge each piece according to the different criticisms and then judge them from our own perspectives.

Comment by Natalee Biggs
Great work girls! I loved the art project we did at the end of the lesson. I think it could be applied to any subject. The students could use the containers to show what they have learned at the end of a unit by creating pictures and describing them on the back. Criticism is very prevalent in our everyday lives and it is important that we teach our students not to judge things too quickly. The teacher can help her students by teaching them how to evaluate and then letting them form their own opinions. In history lessons the teacher should show all sides to a conflict and let the students decide what they agree with. The class could have a food criticism day where they try many different foods and write down how they taste, feel, smell, ect. The teacher would lead the class in judging each element. At the end the students would choose their favorite food of the choices and describe why it was their favorite. The students would then write a poem or a paragraph describing the food they chose using creative words and language. The class could also have a discussion about first impressions and how we shouldn’t let them keep us from pursuing new things or meeting new people.

Comment by Nayelli Concha
I learned a lot from this lesson! It was really great!I think that for my lesson I would have a discussion about what criticism is and how we can apply it in our lives. I would also talk to them about positive and negative criticism and what are the consequences of each respective type of criticism. People see things differently and I like to think that every person has their own pair of glasses which have been formed from their own life experiences, family, culture, gender, etc. For a cool activity, I would ask the children to explore their own glasses and make a list, a web or have an assignment about what unique experiences have shaped their own pair of glasses and they way they see things. Along with that, I would have a discussion about how our differences make us unique and special in this world. For another activity I would ask the kids to think about something that they don't like.. It can be food, a person, a game, etc.. and try to get out of their comfort zone and get involve in an activity where they can find as many things as they can about that object, food or person and see if this activity can change they way they think about the object, food or person that they choose.

Comment by Brielle Romney
If I were to teach this lesson again, I would probably take more time on teaching kids the fundamentals and basics of critiquing. I know we went over it, but with more time, it would help the kids to have more of a basis on critiquing, so they can see the importance of it, and the importance of backing up their views with basic fundamentals and viewpoints. i think the kids will really enjoy critiquing, I just want to make sure they do it semi-credentially

Comment by Rachael Haught
I really enjoyed this lesson! I liked when you challenged everyone's opinion about what they believed to be beautiful. I would really like to take the kiddos to a musuem to see what has been a standard of good art past and present

Comment by Karyn Alvey
Great Job girls! I really liked your lesson. The craft at the end was so creative. I want to make a bunch for friends and family. :) I loved it. An idea for an adaption of this lesson could be to include history. While learning about wars/different events, you could talk about the decisions people made and the consequences that resulted. While discussing, you could ask the students what they would do if they were in the situation. Would they do a similar thing or would they do something different? Great job girlies!

Comment by Rachael Haught
I thought the snack was so creative for this activity. I think that I would have the students learn some basics of line, texture, shape, etc in order to have a foundation in art basics. Then I think I would have the students pretend they were art critics based on the things they had learned. I would set up different works from various artists and have them explain what is good art and what is bad. They then have to defend their critiques. I would wrap up the lesson with the idea that different art is not bad art and there are many types or media that can be used to create. I might even have them take their favorite media (paint, paper, play doh, candy) and have them make their own piece of art work and defend why it is good art.

Comment by Ellen Funch
I think a cool tangent of this lesson would be to have each child pick a culture or a people from any country in the world, either their own heritage or a culture they don't know about, and have them research what is beautiful. I would have them make a collage of what their chosen culture saw as beautiful and have them present it to the class. It would be really cool to hear about that many different cultures and how each of them criticize beauty in a different way!

Comment by Mandy Turner
To improve on this lesson plan, I would take more time to cover the different critiquing criteria throughout history. This would go perfectly with teaching world history. As kids were learning about certain times, events, and people, I could place renown pictures from that time and teach the kids why they were so well accepted. Also, maybe connect the criticism skills they have learned to the activity in a bit more practical way.The class could look at food and critique it using all of their senses. They can discuss why the same food prepared different ways can have opposite results. This could lead in to a discussion on any literature the class is reading. Their responses will be better founded now that they have a better basis for critiquing.

Comment by Nancy
This was a great lesson. It would be really fun to teach the kids about criticism of artwork and when it is okay and not okay to criticize. I think that it would be a good idea to have the kids practice being critics and look at different famous pieces because they would probably really enjoy that.

Comment by Tiffany Baum
Well for me I wasn't able to come to class when this lesson was presented, but from reading the lesson plan, I think one thing that I would add or do differently would be would to be that I would give the students a theme, for their containers.

Day 09 of Class - 9 March 2009

Posted by: Emily Kruszynski:

today we looked at Schools of Criticism & ate cheese and crackers & while drinking "wine" to remind us that, like wine there are different kinds of schools of criticism, some good/some bad, depending on the content & context, and one must evaluate in order to decide which school or wine works best for them (which they like or esteem as "good") we discussed teaching our students to reserve judgement for later (not be so quick to judge). It made me think about how we as LDS teachers can teach good/moral/gospel principles through art this way (indirectly, of course). Teaching is a nobel calling!! I liked the following quote in the Power Point presentation... "The greater the artist, the greater the doubt. Perfect confidence is granted to the less talented as a consolation prize." (by art critic Robert Hughes). So don't worry so much about whether your art is good or bad, just make art..the doubt means you're just more talented ;) at least according to Robert! During the second half of class, Dan had midterm interviews with you while the rest of the class worked on making cool, pop-up boxes (great idea, I did something like that in high school where we had to present each period in art history with a description on the back in a creative way..and this would be great for that).

Posted by Dan Barney

Oh just a thought as I read Emily's description of drinking wine... I am not sure there are bad/good schools of criticism, just different ones that focus on certain qualities. For example, just because a wine may be described as fruity, earthy, and sweet does not mean it is good or bad. Its qualities just make it appropriate for certain juxtapositions or contexts. Recognizing its qualities is helpful but not a full experience for every moment and every situation. Likewise, I think that different criticism models and various aesthetic theories are helpful (but not bad or good) in pointing us toward a variety of qualities that would be difficult to notice otherwise. So, in art, these perspectives really are perspectives; they help us see what we might normally miss or ignore.

Queer Theory Lesson Plan

Teachers: Rachael Haught and Natalee Biggs
Title: Queer Theory
Grade Level: 5th or 6th
Time Needed: 30-45 minutes
Exploration: Students will explore Queer theory and different artists associated with it. They will create their own piece of Queer theory art.
Objective: Students will learn that art can come in many different forms-not just the classic forms of painting or sculpture. Art can be used to make a statement or evoke a feeling.
State Standard (Utah): Grade 5 Visual Arts
Standard 3 Objective 1: Explore possible content in art prints or works of art.
Grade 5 Visual Arts Standard 4 Objective 1: Compare the arts of different cultures to explore their similarities and diversities.
National Standard: Visual Arts Grades 5-8: Understanding the visual arts in relation to history and cultures. o Students know and compare the characteristics of artworks in various eras and cultures o Students describe and place a variety of art objects in historical and cultural contexts o Students analyze, describe, and demonstrate how factors of time and place (such as climate, resources, ideas, and technology) influence visual characteristics that give meaning and value to a work of art

Question of Inquiry: What non-traditional forms of art are being created and what are the motivations for creating them? What has been normalized in society and how are those things being represented or questioned?
Concepts/Vocabulary: Queer Theory Artists Discussed: Pepón Osorio, Collier Schorr, Felix Gonzales Torres, Luiz Luxvich, Martin Waugh, Fotoopa, Pablo Picasso, Manet, and Other Subject Connections: English (Creative Writing)
Teacher Visuals/Supplies: examples of queer theory art, long, skinny balloons, permanent markers
Preparation: Collect different examples of Queer Theory art, learn different ways of making balloon animals, create animal balloon prototype with words describing a passion.
Student Materials: balloon and a permanent marker Lesson
Sequence:
Introduction:
-Define Queer Theory and discuss what it is all about.
Demonstration:
-Show works of Picasso and Manet and compare and contrast them with traditional art pieces. Discuss their motivations and how their art affected people of their time. -Show clip from Improv everywhere (cited below) and discuss how art can be created in many different ways. It doesn’t have to be something on paper or what we would typically think of as art.
-Show works of Felix Gonzales
-Torres and discuss the motivation for his pieces.
-Show Attila Csorgo and discuss context and why it is disturbing for a horse to be stuffed, but not other animals in a museum.
-Show works of Pepon Osorio and video clip (cited below). Tell stories from his culture and how they became motivation for his pieces. Share experiences that were supposed to be a celebration that ended up being traumatizing or not as they were supposed to be.
-Show water drop art and discuss whether or not the students think that they are art. -Show works of Collier Schorr and have a discussion on her motivation. Also discuss stereotypes and the facades that are common in society.
Work Time:
-Demonstration of how to create balloon animals and show prototype -Give examples of creative words
-Students create their own animals
-Each student will write words on his/her animal describing a passion that he/she has.
Clean Up and Management:
-Put markers away -Place balloon animals in a designated area for the remainder of the school day
Closure:
-Review Queer Theory and the idea that art can be expressed in many different ways. Assessment:
-Class discussion about the artists (what did they like? how did each artist’s culture influence his/her work?, ect.)
-Students volunteer to share their balloon animals with the class and the words they used to describe their passion.
Reflection: We could add more emphasis on the cultural influences that motivated the artists discussed and show more historical examples of Queer art and how they were “strange” for their time period.

Resources and References: Felix Gonzales-Torres http://www.queerculturalcenter.org/Pages/FelixGT/FelixBio.html http://www.cmoa.org/international/html/art/gonzalez-torres.htm http://www.huliq.com/22244/felix-gonzalez-torres-represent-exhibiti... http://www.queerculturalcenter.org/Pages/FelixGT/FelixIntro.html Pepon Osorio www.chicano.ucla.edu/research/PEPONOSORIO.html http://americanart.si.edu/collections/exhibits/kscope/osorioexhfram... http://www.pbs.org/art21/slideshow/?slide=965&showindex=78 “No Crying allowed in the Barbershop” video: http://www.pbs.org/cgi-registry/mediaplayer/videoplayer.cgi?playera... Collier Schorr http://www.pbs.org/art21/artists/schorr/index.html http://www.andrew-wyeth-prints.com/helga.html Improv Everywhere Video: http://laughingsquid.com/111-shirtless-men-go-shopping-at-abercromb... State Standards: http://www.uen.org/core/ National Standards: http://www.education-world.com/standards/national/toc/index.shtml




Reply by Kim Brown
To explore the Queer Theory, I'd like to have my class choose one subject matter that is seen daily to create a project about (maybe a student's desk, or a school bus) and try to look at that mundane thing and recreate it or use it as inspiration to create something else. They could use various media. It would be really cool to see all the different ways to look at something that is seemingly mundane.

Reply by Brooke Stevenson
To adapt this lesson to my own classroom I think it would be fun to find books that fit with the queer theory and read them in class. They could be illustrated unusually, told in an unusual way, or include something else unusual. One example could be The True Story of the Three Little Pigs by Jon Scieszka. This book tells a familiar story from a different perspective. There are many other options of books that could be used.

Reply by Karyn Alvey
I loved your lesson! Great job! I thought the use of the Abercrombie store video was quite effective. I've never really thought about how random and strange it is to have the models in there-but yea, it's weird. Another thing we could include in this lesson is how women torture themselves, wearing uncomfortable shoes, to look cute! People don't think twice about how it. The purpose of a shoe is to provide comfortable protection- but many people throw that thought out the window, all for the sake of fashion. I admit I'm guilty of this myself and never really worried about it either, until my brother went off on a tangent one day. I think it's kind of funny now. I loved the balloons! I've always wanted to learn how to make balloon animals. We could incorporate making balloons in animals in a biology class after learning about different animals. :) Great job ladies!

Reply by Amanda Morgan
Wow this lesson was so great! I learned a ton! I really liked the quote from Carolyn Christov-Bakagiev- I felt that her definition of the Queer Theory was dead on! In my classroom to challenge the norm I would ask students to find objects in the classroom and have them analyze it. I want them to realize that an object does not only have one purpose. It can have multiple purposes. I would also want them to take this lesson home and discuss it with their families and bring back an object from home that has been normalized. The activity of balloon animals was great!

Reply by Nichole Mahas
awesome lesson. I would definitely have my class create their own queer theory art, inspired by the art discussed in the lesson. I would encourage the students to come up with a very bizarre way to demonstrate an idea through art. I would tell them to really go the extra mile to find a totally new art medium that we do not use in class. I think this would really get them thinking outside the box about the queer theory.

Reply by Rebecca Ferguson
This lesson was so fun. I think it is especially applicable to Rube Goldberg science projects, and the way that a huge machine can be made out of everyday objects. I really love how this lesson can be fitted for any grade level.

Reply by Brittany Crowder
You guys did awesome!! I think in order to make this lesson my own I might reinforce the idea that the Queer theory includes art being expressed in many different and unusual ways. I might explain this to my students and then have them go throughout the week observing the world around them and trying to find ways in which the art around them can be "queer". This could include buildings, statues, clothes, anything.

Reply by Tiffany Baum
You guys did a great job. Personally for me, I would have showed different types of queer art forms, and the many different ways there are to make art, I know you had some pictures, I would just try to have forms in the class room.

Reply by Ellen Funch
This lesson was wonderful! For some reason I have had a really hard time thinking about how i could incorporate this into my classroom, but something i think that would be cool after teaching this theory and lesson would be to teach the kids about sociology. Sociology is full of ironies and we could take the time to look around us at social ironies. I think it would be a cool project for the kids to apply to their lives. I was thinking we could talk about why we do what we do, why we talk the way we do, or act the way we do, and give them an assignment for a week to find a social norm that they do, and to break it. I would love for them to record how it feels to maybe stand up for someone when they are being picked on, or to offer help to someone that maybe might not need it, or compliment someone if they are a more shy personality. I think this would be a really cool activity for the beginning of the year to kind of break kids out of their comfort zone because we would all be doing it together and this would hopefully create a type of bond. Plus how fun would it be to dance around school instead of walk (another example)?! So great!

Reply by Nancy
I think another idea for this lesson would be to have your class bring in objects from home and then have them recreate them in an unusual way through any median.

Reply by Brett Baldry
I think that a fun way to adopt this into my classroom would be to have a lesson on individuality. You could talk about how its okay to step out of the social mold and be the person that you want to be. I would then have a dress up day where kids can where something crazy to school that they feel allows them to break the traditional mold of dress.

Reply by Brielle Romney
Great lesson! I think it would be interesting to talk about the differences of the definition of the word "queer" today, and what it was back then. That might be a good introduction to the lesson. Maybe even write a little paper on it or something. You can also talk about other words whose meanings have changed over time, and why that might be. What cultural and societal acceptances have changed, and what changes have been made in general?

Reply by Nayelli Concha
I just realized I never comment on this theory apparently but this was one of my favorite presentations. I learned a lot about this theory and about challenging our minds by looking at different artworks that we are used to. I loved the quote you used on your slide that said "It is when our minds are confused that we begin to change" If we are not exposed to new and different things how is it that we are foing to learn and grow?

Reply by Mandy Turner
I think your "Question of Inquiry" is a great prompt for students. Instead of feeling restricted by the normalized idea of art and focusing on that, kids are taught that their artwork begins with their emotions which are then displayed in their artwork. At a sensitive time in their life it's good for kids to realize they can do something different and have it be great. I would emphasis the different trends throughout the ages and how they were previously unaccepted initially. Kids could then think of things that aren't accepted now and how its acceptance would change the status quo.